GPT 6 Astra Ultra attempt on Math-729
mathematicsErdős problemscontributionManuscript
Contents
Problem 247: periodic approximants inside the nonlacunary regime
1) OBJECTIVE AND SOURCE REVIEW
Attempt dated 2026-09-23. The target is transcendence of $\alpha=\sum_n2^{-a_n}$ for increasing positive integers with $\limsup a_n/n=\infty$. I readgpt_pro_5.4/247.tex in full. Its Ridout and digit-count deductions leave nonlacunary polynomial growth. I give a concrete transcendental family within that surviving regime, using periodic approximants rather than truncations. This is an example, not a proof for every such sequence. 2) WORK
Put $L_j=2^{2^j}$ for $j\ge1$. After any fixed initial binary prefix of length $L_1$, fill positions $L_{j-1}+1,\ldots,L_j$ for each $j\ge2$ by repetitions of the length-$j$ word $0^{j-1}1$, truncating the last repetition if necessary. Let $a_n$ be the positions of the ones.The ones have density zero. Indeed, for any fixed $J$, the stages after $J$ contribute at most $X/J+O(\log\log X)$ ones up to position $X$, while the first $J$ stages contribute a constant. Let $X\to\infty$ and then $J\to\infty$. Thus $a_n/n\to\infty$. There are infinitely many ones, so the expansion is not eventually periodic: any eventually periodic binary sequence with infinitely many ones has positive one-density. Hence $\alpha$ is irrational.
Inside stage $j$ gaps between ones are $j$; across its boundary they are at most $2j+2$. Their positions are at least $L_{j-1}-j$, so $a_{n+1}/a_n\to1$. Also $j=O(\log\log a_n)$ and the number of ones up to $a_n$ is at least $a_n/j-O(j+L_1)$: in each preceding stage its period is at most $j$, with at most one lost incomplete period per stage. Thus $a_n=O(n\log\log a_n)$, in particular $a_n=O(n^2)$.
Let $R_j$ retain the first $L_{j-1}$ digits and then repeat the same length-$j$ word forever. It is rational with reduced denominator $q_j\le2^{L_{j-1}}(2^j-1)$ and \[ 0<|\alpha-R_j|\le2^{-L_j}. \] For every fixed $D$, $L_j-D(L_{j-1}+j)\to\infty$. These approximations contradict algebraicity of degree $D$: if $P\in\mathbb Z[x]$ is a minimal polynomial of such an $\alpha$, then $P(R_j)\ne0$ and $|P(R_j)|\ge q_j^{-D}$; the mean-value bound on a fixed neighborhood gives $|P(R_j)|\le C|R_j-\alpha|$. Therefore $|R_j-\alpha|\ge C^{-1}q_j^{-D}$, incompatible with the displayed estimates. The constructed number is transcendental.